Criticism of Penang South Islands reclamation grows

The Consumers Association of Penang (CAP) has raised concerns over the Penang state government’s plans for South Islands land reclamation project, urging them to listen to civil society organizations (CSOs) and the public’s voices.

The focus is on whether the proposed reclamation, whether for one or three islands, is necessary and outweighs the negative ecological and social impacts.

The Prime Minister has called for a review of the project to assess its necessity and benefits to the people. CAP emphasizes the importance of involving independent experts and CSOs in the review process.

Environmental and social impacts of the reclamation

CAP highlights the potential negative consequences of the reclamation project, including damage to fishery spawning grounds, marine habitats, and shrimp migration routes.

The destruction of mud flats and coral reefs would have far-reaching effects on the ecosystem, not only impacting fishermen in the immediate vicinity but also those in Penang, Kedah, and Perak waters.

The large-scale extraction of sand from Penang or Perak waters for reclamation purposes further exacerbates environmental concerns.

The proposed South Islands project is closely connected to the expansion of the Penang Light Rail Transit (LRT) system.

The state government envisions the reclamation as a means to fund the LRT project and attract tourists to the newly created island(s), with one of them being named Silicon Island.

However, CAP questions the need for such extensive reclamation to finance the LRT when the federal government has already committed funds for improving Penang’s transport infrastructure.

Alternatives for the Penang South Islands project

CAP argues that there is no need for extensive reclamation, given the promised funding by the federal government for improving Penang’s transport infrastructure, including the proposed Penang LRT system.

The organization points out that there is ample available land for economic development, with around 30,000 acres on the mainland and 1,300 acres on the island. CAP emphasizes that the Chief Minister’s own admission of 12,000 hectares of land in Seberang Perai further diminishes the justification for extensive reclamation.

CAP concludes by calling upon the Chief Minister of Penang to provide a clear explanation for the necessity of the extensive reclamation project. It urges the state government not to commit to any financial liabilities until the independent review process is completed and voices from CSOs and the informed public are considered.

The organization stresses the need to prioritize the preservation of the environment and the concerns of the local communities over the pressure from developers and contractors.

By voicing their concerns, CAP aims to encourage a balanced and thorough evaluation of the project’s impacts and explore alternative options that prioritize sustainable development and environmental preservation.