
A residents’ association cannot automatically make a homeowner a member, the Shah Alam Sessions Court has ruled. It also cannot demand retrospective security fees as the price of joining.
The case involved a homeowner who challenged Persatuan Penduduk Jalan Hijau Pelangi and its chairman. The dispute was over seven years of security fees that built up while he was living overseas.
The court awarded the homeowner RM20,000 in damages and ordered the association to give him an access card. The ruling matters for homeowners in guarded neighbourhoods who face fee demands. It also matters for associations that collect security fees from residents.
What the court said about residents’ association membership

Sessions Court judge Zuhrina Nor Hakim allowed the homeowner’s civil claim. She found that the association could not impose membership on him.
She also held that the association could not make payment of past security fees a condition for membership. The ruling covers fees demanded for earlier years.
The court dismissed the counterclaim by the association and its chairman, Saaidal Razalli Azzuhri. That means their own claim against the homeowner failed too. It ordered them to pay RM20,000 in general damages, plus RM7,000 in costs.
The damages carry 5 per cent annual interest from the date of judgment. The decision was delivered on Monday 16 November, according to reports. The case turns on whether membership can simply be assumed.
The security fee dispute behind the case

The homeowner is Abdul Farid Abdul Kadir. The association said he had become a member automatically. It then claimed security fees that built up from 2013, which is the core of the residents’ association dispute.
He said he never applied to join, and that he was away from the neighbourhood during those years. He argued that the association’s rules require a voluntary application, so the association cannot impose membership on an owner.
READ MORE: Island Glades residents voice concerns over bypass project
READ MORE: Residents, NGO urge stricter enforcement following dog attack incident
READ MORE: PJ residents celebrate Chap Goh Meh night of love at Taman Jaya Park
The association set a condition when he offered to pay. It wanted him to settle the old security arrears first, which he refused to do.
The court also ordered the defendants to give him an access card within 30 days. It further ordered a refund or set-off of RM1,410 that he had paid towards the disputed fees.
What the ruling means for homeowners and residents’ associations

For homeowners, the ruling means a residents’ association cannot treat you as a member without your consent. It also means a demand for years of past fees may not stand.
For associations, the message is that membership and fee rules must follow their own constitution. Joining should be a voluntary step, not an automatic one. The decision shows that a bill for past fees alone is not enough.
This is one Sessions Court decision in one case, and the written judgment may add detail. It does not change the law for every neighbourhood, and an appeal is possible. Homeowners with a similar dispute should read their association’s rules and keep copies of every letter and receipt. Written records help if a dispute reaches court.
Owners who want to know how this affects them can seek legal advice. Homeowners should also verify credentials before hiring contractors, as CJ.MY has reported, because disputes over homes are costly.












Add comment